Money at 30: The Pros and Cons of Credit Card Upgrade Offers Credit Card Upgrade Offers: A Look at the Pros and Cons
gift wrapped credit card

Money at 30: The Pros and Cons of Credit Card Upgrade Offers

Having been a personal finance writer for more than five years now, it’s become common for friends of mine to ask me questions about a variety of money topics. That’s why my buddy Josh was excited to call me this afternoon and tell me about a credit card offer he’d just accepted. In his case, American Express reached out and offered him the opportunity to upgrade his Gold Card to a Platinum Card. If he did so and spent $6,000 on his new card, he’d receive 100,000 Membership Rewards points. Plus, to sweeten the deal and make up for the loss of the Gold card’s perks, he’d also earn 5x points on dining and supermarket purchases for the next six months.

Obviously this seems like a pretty good deal — which is why he took it. However, the decision to accept such an offer might not be so simple in every case or for every person. With that in mind, let’s take a look at a few pros and cons to consider before opting for a credit card upgrade offer.

The Benefits of Taking a Credit Card Upgrade

A point/cashback windfall

The most obvious perk that comes with accepting a credit card upgrade is that it could come with a boatload of points and/or cashback. For example, the 100,000 points my friend was offered made it pretty hard to say “no” — especially with the bonus 5x components. Although spending category rewards and other offers can help consumers to rack up points, the truth is that most people get the greatest benefit from welcome bonuses and the like. So, getting an injection of points like this might make a lot of sense depending on your situation.

“Test drive” a product

Something else that might make a card upgrade worth it is that it could provide an opportunity to try the benefits of a card on for size. In the case of the Amex Platinum, perhaps you’re curious about the lounge access it offers or the $200 Fine Hotels and Resorts/Hotel Collection credit. Since it can be difficult to know how much value you’d get out of these perks before applying, the upgrade may make it easier to find out. Then, if you don’t get the value you were expecting…

Downgrade afterward

As I was just alluding to, something else to note about upgrade offers is you can typically downgrade again once your initial year is up. By the way, this is often true of credit cards you sign up for directly as well — but seems even more understandable when the reason you got a card in the first place was that the issuer asked you to. Of course, before accepting an offer, you will want to confirm that you can downgrade without penalty and still retain your points.

Potential Downsides to Consider

Additional spending

The first potential downside of credit upgrade offers is that they may have a minimum spending requirement. Similar to regular welcome bonuses, your points/cashback may be contingent on you putting a set amount of spend on your card within a certain timeframe. For example, for my friend’s bonus, he’d need to spend at least $6,000 on the card during his first six months. Because of this, you’ll need to make sure that you can meet the required spend and timeframe — and without making purchases you wouldn’t otherwise make.

Higher annual fee

Another consideration to make is that you’ll likely need to pay a higher annual fee for your upgraded card. Even if a one-year waived fee may be part of the deal, this still means you’ll need to pay the fee once your first year is up. In the case of my friend’s Platinum upgrade, he did need to pay the $695 annual fee with his first statement (although he was given a prorated refund on his Gold card’s $250 annual fee at the same time). Also, keep in mind that annual fees don’t typically count toward your initial spending bonus tally, so make sure you budget for both.

Future welcome bonuses ineligibility

This one is more specific to American Express, which has some pretty strict rules on welcome offers. Normally, Amex’s offers have a “once in a lifetime” rule — meaning that, if you get an upgrade for a card a receive a bonus, you likely won’t be able to get a welcome bonus for that card in the future. Because of this, you’ll want to ensure that the upgrade offer you’re getting is worth it and at least comparable to the current welcome bonus. Otherwise, you could be doing yourself a disservice in the long run.

Mismatched/unneeded rewards

Finally, speaking of the long run, sometimes a card upgrade simply won’t make sense for your lifestyle. While the Platinum card has all kinds of great travel benefits, it’s admittedly a very different product from the Gold card that emphasizes dining and grocery spending instead. Thus, for some people, the short-term gains that come with the upgrade offer might not make the card worth it overall (especially when the higher annual fee is taken into account). As I mentioned earlier, there may be an opportunity to downgrade after the first year if you do find this to be the case, but just keep in mind that you may be sacrificing some benefits in the meantime.

While credit card upgrade offers may not be quite as common as regular credit card solicitation, they do happen from time to time. When they do, it may be worth taking a closer look at what the offer is, how the card in question will benefit you, what spending you’ll need to do, and whether you can downgrade after the intro period if you want to. With these considerations, you’ll hopefully be able to assess whether these upgrade opportunities are right for you, whether you’re better off sticking with your current card, or whether it might be better to just apply for the other card separately. No matter what you decide, just be sure that it makes the most sense for your situation.


Kyle Burbank

Head Writer ~ Fioney
Kyle is the head writer for Fioney. He is a personal finance nerd, constantly looking for new apps and services to test and incorporate into his own financial game plan. In addition to his role at Fioney, he's written for other publications including Born2Invest, Lifehack, and Laughing Place, as well as his own site Money@30. He also creates personal finance and travel-related videos for Money@30's YouTube channel, which has garnered more than 2 million views. Currently, Kyle resides in Springfield, Missouri with his wife of 10 years. Together, they enjoy traveling (including visiting Disney Parks around the world), dining, and playing with their dog Rigby.

Other Articles by Kyle Burbank

2023 Small Business Credit Card Satisfaction Tops 2019 Highs

The latest small business credit card study from J.D. Power shows satisfaction continuing to rise. About the study and results: This week, J.D Power released its 2023 U.S. Small Business Credit Card Satisfaction Study, which includes responses from more than 3,400 small business credit card customers. In this case, the study looked at businesses with annual revenues between $10,000 and $10 million. First, it was discovered that overall satisfaction among...

Discover Announces 5% Bonus Categories for First Quarter of 2024

With 2024 sneaking up on us, Discover has announced its rotating 5% bonus categories for the first quarter of next year. About the Q1 2024 bonus categories: From January through March 2024, Discover It customers will be able to earn up to 5% back in two categories: restaurants and drugstores. According to the company, the Restaurants category includes full-service establishments, cafes, cafeterias, fast-food locations, and dining delivery services. For the...

Public App Adds Corporate and Treasury Bonds Feature

The FinTech trading app Public has announced new investment options for its members. About the features: Public is now rolling out the ability for customers to invest fractionally in corporate and Treasury bonds. This capability will be introduced on both the mobile and desktop interfaces for the service. According to Public, the addition comes as demand for fixed-income products increases. In addition to these bond types, the app will also...
The "Email" field is empty, you must enter some text to proceed.The text you entered in the "Email" field appears to be invalid, please edit it and try again
Get the Latest News Delivered to Your Inbox

FedEx Announces Winners of 11th Annual 2023 Small Business Grant Contest

Nearly three months after the entry period ended, FedEx has announced the winners of its 11th annual Small Business Grant Content. This year's event saw more than $300,000 in funds going to a variety of small businesses across the nation. Last month, the company revealed 100 finalists, with that list now being narrowed down to just 10 winners. This year's grand prize winners included KindVR, The Cupcake Collection, Up In...
Summer app

Student Loan Benefit FinTech Summer Raises $6 Million

For years, student debt has been one of the most talked about financial topics. What's more, while the debt itself has become a major part of many Americans' lives, discussion of student loans has become political due to efforts to forgive certain loan repayments. However, while we wait for resolution on that front, a FinTech that brings student debt benefit solutions to employers and consumers has raised a new round...
H-E-B and Central Market  credit cards

Imprint Launches Credit Cards from H-E-B and Central Market 

The FinTech Imprint is partnering with the popular Texas-based grocery chain H-E-B for a pair of new rewards credit cards. This week saw the launch of the H-E-B Visa Signature Credit Card as well as the Central Market Visa Signature Credit Card. With these two (nearly identical) options, customers will be able to earn rewards on groceries and beyond. First, both versions of the card earn up to 5% back on select...
Melissa Urban holding a Ness card

Health and Wellness Rewards Card Ness Partners with Whole30

In recent years, several unique rewards cards have come to market. These include offerings from FinTech startups as well as brands looking to do something special for their loyal fans. On that note, a recently-announced rewards credit card offering is now working with a popular brand to introduce new benefits for customers. This week, the Ness Card (which is issued by The Bank of Missouri) unveiled a new partnership with...
Choice Privileges Select Card

Choice Hotels, Wells Fargo Debut Choice Privileges Select Card

With spring well underway and the summer travel season now just around the corner, Choice Hotels and Wells Fargo have unveiled their latest co-branded credit card offering. Today, the two companies announced the Choice Privileges Select Mastercard. Carrying an annual fee of $95, this card will serve as the premium option in the hotel brand's new lineup. Looking at the Choice Privileges Select, it offers a mix of rewards categories....