Are FinTech Accounts Worth it When APYs are High?
FinTech bank illustration

Money at 30: Are FinTech Accounts Worth it When APYs are High?

After more than two years of near-nothing interest rates, high-yield savings accounts are back. Over the past several weeks, APYs across several accounts have skyrocketed and, in many cases, are now pushing toward 2% APY (as of this writing, that is). And, with the Federal Reserve widely expected to keep raising interest rates, these could go even higher shortly. So, the question for me has become: If more traditional savings accounts are paying high APYs, is it still worth dealing with some of the gimmicks of FinTech?

The problem with FinTech right now

Keep in mind, I say this as someone who’s been a big fan of the financial technology sector and who has reviewed dozens of these services before. In that time, I’ve seen services come and go, offerings get overhauled, and, yes, watched as APYs crashed and then rebounded. On that note, while most institutions and many other accounts slashed their rates in 2020 and beyond, there were still a handful of platforms that featured solid rates — you just had to work for them.

For example, a customer might need to make a certain number of purchases on a debit card per month in order to unlock an increased rate or, on the other end of things, may be required to directly deposit a set dollar amount on a regular basis to keep earning that enhanced rate. Furthermore, while these whole-digit APYs looked good in comparison to the decimal-followed-by-a-zero rates found elsewhere, they’d also often only apply on limited balances with higher savings earning lower rates. For example, Varo Bank requires you to have direct deposit of at least $1000/month but no more than $4,999 in your savings account to qualify for its 5% APY.

These requirements could legitimately be a big issue for a number of startups that have attempted to attract new customers by offering eye-popping interest rates (while downplaying the restrictions). Without this advantage — and with crypto frenzy dying down for the moment — I wouldn’t be surprised if we see more startups failing to meet their active user goals. Then again, there is the hope that perhaps the more creative FinTechs can come up with new features and offerings that will make their platforms worth trying. As it stands, it seems as though the “neobank” concept is growing to be homogenized as more intriguing twists on digital banking like Bella Loves Me failed to catch on.

The problem with “FDIC insured”

As I recently wrote about, one of the confusing aspects of FinTech is that, while funds are FDIC insured thanks to partner banks that startups hold deposits with, it’s unclear exactly what happens if these companies were to disappear without returning customer funds. That’s because, technically, the insurance covers deposits in the event that the bank itself fails, not if the immediacies go away. Because of this, while I continue to believe that most FinTech apps are fairly safe on the whole, they are not without at least some bit of risk.

Thus, when given the choice to earn 2% APY by keeping money directly with an FDIC insured bank or 3% APY by depositing money via an app (that will then keep the money with a bank), it’s understandable that many consumers would rather take the path of least resistance. To some degree, I’m right there with them on this point as, while I store at least a few dollars with a number of different FinTech apps, the bulk of my cash remains in more “traditional” accounts — although Current is a notable exception to this.

So… are FinTechs worth it in the current environment?

Ultimately, at this time, I’m much more inclined to simply rely on accounts such as Marcus, Discover, Ally, and others where I can get a solid APY on my savings without jumping through hoops. At the same time, I do think there’s still a space for FinTechs and different types of accounts. Unfortunately, finding new and interesting products that will stick around is becoming a bit more difficult by the day. But, thankfully, that’s what I’m here for — so stay tuned.

Author

Kyle Burbank

Head Writer ~ Fioney
Kyle is the head writer for Fioney. He is a personal finance nerd, constantly looking for new apps and services to test and incorporate into his own financial game plan. In addition to his role at Fioney, he's written for other publications including Born2Invest, Lifehack, and Laughing Place, as well as his own site Money@30. He also creates personal finance and travel-related videos for Fioney's YouTube channel, which has garnered more than 2 million views. Currently, Kyle resides in Springfield, Missouri with his wife of 10 years. Together, they enjoy traveling (including visiting Disney Parks around the world), dining, and playing with their dog Rigby.

Other Articles by Kyle Burbank

Bilt and Southwest Airlines logos

Bilt Rewards Adds Southwest Airlines as Latest Travel Transfer Partner

Bilt Rewards is at it again — this time adding another notable travel brand to its point transfer program. About the Addition of Southwest Airlines: This morning, Bilt announced that it would be partnering with Southwest Airlines. As a result, Bilt members can now transfer their Bilt Points to Southwest's Rapid Rewards Program at a rate of 1:1. With the addition of Southwest, Bilt now has a total of 19 travel...
phones with apps and headphones

Blinkist Review: What Is It and Is It Worth the Price?

Over the years, I’ve made an effort to read/listen to more finance books and review them (in fact, this year, I’ve renewed my goal to review at least one book a month here on the site). While that may seem simple enough, it means not only finding books that interest me but also finding the time to consume them. That’s why I was interested when I came across the service...
Bilt Rewards student loans repayment screenshot

Bilt Rewards Adds Student Loan Payment Redemption Option

Bilt is adding a new and unique redemption option for its members. About Bilt Point Student Loan Redemptions: Today, Bilt Rewards revealed that members could now redeem their Bilt Points toward a student loan payment. Effectively, this means that customers can chip away at their student debt just by paying their rent. To get started with this redemption option, customers will first need to connect their loan servicer. Currently, loans...

Leave a Reply

The "Email" field is empty, you must enter some text to proceed.The text you entered in the "Email" field appears to be invalid, please edit it and try again
Get the Latest News Delivered to Your Inbox
Travelers with two Best Western Credit Cards

Best Western Debuts Two New Rewards Credit Cards

After pausing applications for their previous rewards card, the hotel chain Best Western has unveiled a new pair of rewards credit cards with a new issuer. About the Best Western cards: Best Western is partnering with First Bank & Trust and Mercury Financial to introduce two new co-branded credit cards. First up is the no-annual-fee Best Western Rewards Visa Signature Card. With this card, customers can 4x points on Best...
Marriott Bonvoy card and a woman on vacation

Marriott Bonvoy Bold Card Launches Travel Contest

Chase and Marriott Bonoy have unveiled a special contest while continuing to offer its best-ever welcome bonus. About the welcome bonus and Bold Chat Court Contest: Marriott Bonvoy and Chase have launched a special opportunity called the Bold Chat Court contest. As part of this contest, 10 lucky travelers will be awarded 500,000 Marriott Bonvoy points (for a total of 5 million) as well as $5,000. For this contest, the...
Bilt and All Reward logos

Bilt Adds 2 New Transfer Partners Including First 3:2 Transfer Rate

Bilt is once again expanding its travel transfer rewards program — and is even breaking the mold with one new partner. About the new additions to Bilt: This week, Bilt launched partnerships with two more travel brands: TAP Air Portugal and Accor. As a result, Bilt members will now be able to transfer their points to Miles&Go and ALL Reward, respectively. In total, Bilt now has 18 transfer partners including 13...

2025 SoFi Checking and Savings Review

 Ever since I started taking an interest in the FinTech sector, one company whose name I’ve seen pop up over and over again is SoFi. That was later sent into overdrive as the company has not only become a household name thanks to its stadium naming rights deal but also because of the company’s continued product expansions. The most interesting development in my mind is SoFi’s acquisition of Golden Pacific...
Fioney Top 10 Must-Read Personal Finance Articles Septemeber 2024

Top 10 Personal Finance Articles of the Month — September 2024

Welcome to Fioney's look at the top 10 personal finance articles of the month. On the first Friday of each new month, we look back at some of our favorite posts published in the weeks prior and highlight them right here. This includes a mix of sites that have become staples of our lists as well as many first-timers. To start things off this month, we'll look at some articles...