The Good and Bad of Door-to-Door Solicitors
woman talking to a salesperson at the front door

Lessons From a First-Time Home Buyer: The Good and Bad of Door-to-Door Solicitors

When we first moved into our home, I noted that one of my least favorite things about living in a house (as compared to an access-controlled apartment building) was the ability for solicitors and other strangers to knock on our door. To be fair, this hasn’t happened with too much frequency — and there is a range of just how obnoxious they are. Well, recently, we had two very different experiences with salespeople knocking on our door, with one resulting in my very first service sign-up from a solicitor… and the other leaving a bad, annoyed taste in my mouth. Here’s what happened.

A Tale of Two Salesmen: My Recent Experiences as a Homeowner

standing on a hoverboard

The Wrong Way to Solicit (Or Why Your Cringe Tactics Won’t Work on Me)

One day, in the evening, I heard a knock on the door followed by the doorbell. This pattern is almost always a soliciter, as those delivering packages usually do one or the other (or nothing at all, really). Immediately, I sigh and head downstairs.

When I answer, I’m greeted by a guy wearing a construction vest and riding a “hoverboard.” He then tells me that he’s from “the trash company,” that they’re starting a new route, that all of my neighbors are signing up, and that they’re going to save me money. Before I can even really speak, he’s already getting his iPad ready as if this were a foregone conclusion.

I should back up and explain that, in Springfield, there is no city-run trash or recycling. Instead, there are a variety of privately-owned companies of varying sizes that service the metro area. Ours is a locally-based service that we’ve used since we moved here. In that time, we haven’t had any issues or missed pick-ups.

Back to the sales guy, this is where I started to ask questions. In response, he pulls a contract from someone nearby to show me how easy it is to sign up. This was also the first time I saw what company he actually worked for.

Ultimately, even though the price he was offering was lower than we pay now (a few dollars a month), I declined the offer. He then asked if I liked saving money, to which I told him, “Nah, I hate it.” Yeah, I was done with this guy.

Unfortunately for the company in question, this salesman’s smarmy tactic made me less likely to trust them. Immediately, I figured there was probably a catch — such as the price increasing after a promotional period — that I didn’t want to be surprised by. Looking back, even though I do see that some of my neighbors made the switch, I’m happy to have stuck with our current company, who I know do a good job rather than take a risk.

pest control worker with a spayer

A Solicitation I Took Them Up On

Cut to last week when the same knock-then-ring pattern sends me back down the stairs and to the door. Funny enough, this pitch started off similarly, with the salesman saying that they were already servicing some of my neighbors. But rather than trash service, this time, they were offering pest control.

Luckily for him, I had already been thinking about pest control for some time. We haven’t had any major issues, but I have wondered if we should have regular service — and how much something like that would cost. Thus, this it at least seemed like an opportunity to get an answer to that latter question.

After taking a look around the exterior, he broke down how the service worked. Basically, I’d pay a one-time upfront fee followed by a monthly amount for quarterly service. Moreover, if we have issues in between those set visits, they’d come out for free and take care of it. Looking at the paperwork, the only slight catch I noticed was that, if we didn’t cancel in writing 30 days before our renewal, it would renew automatically. That’s kind of annoying, but I made a note of it in case we do want to cancel. Hopefully, though, things will go well.

As you can probably tell, I did take him up on the offer. In turn, just two days later, the technician showed up to perform our first service. Now, seeing as it’s only been a few days, it’s hard to say whether things are going well… but the guy was nice and seemed to do a good job.

If there was anything I did wrong in this episode, though, I probably should have looked up the company before signing. The good news here is that, once I did (immediately after he left), I found that they had thousands of positive reviews and an average of 4.9 stars on Google. Phew.

All in all, I’m happy with how this all went down, as it helped me check something off my list without having to seek out a solution. Might I be paying more than I should? It’s possible — but I’m paying an amount I’m happy with. So, maybe door-to-door sales aren’t all that bad after all.


In the two and a half years that we’ve lived in our house, we’ve had dozens of people show up at our door unexpectedly. Sometimes it’s to have a petition signed, sometimes it’s to invite us to church, and sometimes it’s to sell us something. Of the three, the last category is probably my least favorite — with the first interaction I described explaining why I tend to get a sinking feeling when I open the door to salesmen. Yet, as it turns out, there can be upsides to solicitors, provided that they’re 1) honest and 2) offering something you need.

With that, perhaps the next time I hear that signature knock/ring combo, I won’t dread answering quite as much.

Author

Kyle Burbank

Head Writer ~ Fioney
Kyle is the head writer for Fioney. He is a personal finance nerd, constantly looking for new apps and services to test and incorporate into his own financial game plan. In addition to his role at Fioney, he's written for other publications including Born2Invest, Lifehack, and Laughing Place, as well as his own site Money@30. He also creates personal finance and travel-related videos for Fioney's YouTube channel, which has garnered more than 2 million views. Currently, Kyle resides in Springfield, Missouri with his wife of 10 years. Together, they enjoy traveling (including visiting Disney Parks around the world), dining, and playing with their dog Rigby.

Other Articles by Kyle Burbank

CasaPerks logo and a multi-unit apartment

AI-Powered Rewards Platform CasaPerks Raises $15.8 Million

A platform that allows consumers to earn rewards on rent and more has raised a new round of funding. About CasaPerks and the Seed Round: Today, CasaPerks revealed that it had raised $15.8 million. The seed round was led by Longevity Equity and included participation from "top real estate operators" among others. With the funds, CasaPerks plans to continue its expansion. Additionally, the company intends to scale its workplace recognition...

NerdWallet Introduces Monthly "Financial Resilience Index"

The popular personal finance site NerdWallet has premiered a new monthly index meant to highlight how prepared American consumers are for economic uncertainty. About the Financial Resilience Index: This week, NerdWallet introduced the Financial Resilience Index. For this index, the site commissioned Harris Poll to survey 2,072 adults in the United States. These respondents were asked questions across three different categories: financial security, financial strength, and economic outlook. Specifically, the...

Fanatics to Launch Rewards Credit Card with American Express

American Express and Fanatics have announced a partnership that will not only result in a new rewards credit card but will also lead to a new option for other cardholders. About the Fanatics American Express Card: This week, Amex revealed that it was teaming up with the sports merchandise site Fanatics. As part of this partnership, the two will create the Fanatics American Express Card. According to a press release,...
The "Email" field is empty, you must enter some text to proceed.The text you entered in the "Email" field appears to be invalid, please edit it and try again
Get the Latest News Delivered to Your Inbox

2025 SoFi Checking and Savings Review

 Ever since I started taking an interest in the FinTech sector, one company whose name I’ve seen pop up over and over again is SoFi. That was later sent into overdrive as the company has not only become a household name thanks to its stadium naming rights deal but also because of the company’s continued product expansions. The most interesting development in my mind is SoFi’s acquisition of Golden Pacific...
Travelers with two Best Western Credit Cards

Best Western Debuts Two New Rewards Credit Cards

After pausing applications for their previous rewards card, the hotel chain Best Western has unveiled a new pair of rewards credit cards with a new issuer. About the Best Western cards: Best Western is partnering with First Bank & Trust and Mercury Financial to introduce two new co-branded credit cards. First up is the no-annual-fee Best Western Rewards Visa Signature Card. With this card, customers can 4x points on Best...
Marriott Bonvoy card and a woman on vacation

Marriott Bonvoy Bold Card Launches Travel Contest

Chase and Marriott Bonoy have unveiled a special contest while continuing to offer its best-ever welcome bonus. About the welcome bonus and Bold Chat Court Contest: Marriott Bonvoy and Chase have launched a special opportunity called the Bold Chat Court contest. As part of this contest, 10 lucky travelers will be awarded 500,000 Marriott Bonvoy points (for a total of 5 million) as well as $5,000. For this contest, the...
Bilt and All Reward logos

Bilt Adds 2 New Transfer Partners Including First 3:2 Transfer Rate

Bilt is once again expanding its travel transfer rewards program — and is even breaking the mold with one new partner. About the new additions to Bilt: This week, Bilt launched partnerships with two more travel brands: TAP Air Portugal and Accor. As a result, Bilt members will now be able to transfer their points to Miles&Go and ALL Reward, respectively. In total, Bilt now has 18 transfer partners including 13...
PayPal Debit Card app

PayPal Debit Card Review: Earn Stackable 5% Cash Back

In recent weeks, PayPal debuted an updated debit card product (perhaps you've seen the incessant Will Ferrell commercials for it during football games?). With the launch of this card, the company known for online payments is encouraging customers to pay with them anywhere. To encourage such behavior, the debit card allows cardholders to earn 5% cashback — although, as you can imagine, there are some important restrictions on that. So,...