How New Realtor Rules Could Impact Buyers
signing a contract next to a model house and a judge's gavel

Lessons From a First-Time Home Buyer: How New Realtor Rules Could Impact Buyers

You may have heard that the rules for real estate agents and realtors were changing. If you’re like me, you might have even caught a segment about it on your local news… that only managed to make things more confusing. I’m not sure why getting clear answers on these updates has proven so difficult but, in my experience, it has been.

Luckily, among the junk, I have found some clarifying sources that have helped give me a better idea about what the new rules do mean for buyers and what else it could mean for them — so let’s get into it.

New Realtor Rules: The Impact on Homebuyers

magnifying glass and homes illustration

How we got here

As you may or may not realize, the recent rule changes aren’t simply the result of a new idea that real estate agents are looking to try on for size. Instead, they are the result of an anti-trust lawsuit against the National Association of Realtors (NAR). The basic argument was that requiring sellers to offer commissions in order to be placed on a multi-listing service (MLS) kept realtor commissions higher and, in turn, artificially increased the price of homes — with the theory suggesting that the commissions were largely priced into what sellers were asking.

In a $418 million dollar settlement, NAR has agreed to change its rules. So, updates to MLS, commissions, and more went into effect on August 17th, 2024.

What the rule changes mean and the potential impacts

There are really two main changes that buyers should be aware of. First, MLS entries will no longer include commission information. As CNN explains, this update is meant to curb so-called “steering” — a practice where realtors intentionally lead prospective buyers toward homes offering higher commissions.

The other and perhaps more impactful change for buyers involves everyone’s favorite thing: paperwork. Now, buyers and realtors will be required to sign a formal agreement before the agent is able to show them any houses. Of course, open houses are expected to still be a thing, so those just starting their homebuying journey will still have a chance to check out homes without needing to commit.

This part of the update is also where the largest, most notable, and potentially most costly update comes in. As part of this contract, buyers will also need to negotiate a commission for their agent. However, this doesn’t necessarily mean that they’ll end up paying those fees out of pocket. Instead, just as buyers might ask sellers to pay their closing costs as part of their offer, they might now negotiate that the seller also pays their realtor’s commission — but it won’t be a given anymore. Because of this, buyers will likely want to be prepared and factor a potential commission payment into their homebuying budget.

woman holding a model home

How these updates differ from our homebuying experience

Looking over these changes, a couple of things stood out to me as they would have definitely affected our experience buying a home. For one, our realtor showed us a few homes before the topic of signing formal paperwork even came up (I honestly didn’t even realize this was a common practice). We did offer to sign said documents, but we didn’t even get around to it as we ended up finding a home much more quickly than expected.

The other difference is that we absolutely counted on the fact that the seller would be paying the buyer’s commission. If this hadn’t been the default, we probably would have asked for it in our offer as we were already butting up against our upfront payment budget with the closing costs and actual down payment accounted for. So, as someone who’s not great at negotiating, I kind of appreciated that this was baked into the deal (even though I also understated the “artificially inflated” argument).

One aspect of our experience that I don’t think would have been adjusted if we were buying today was the process of finding homes to look at. That’s because our agent set us up with an MLS account and allowed us to simply save properties we were interested in seeing. Then, she’d… well… take us to see them. Therefore, I don’t think it was really possible that she could have been “steering” us at all. I suppose that buyers relying fully on their realtors to show them houses rather than looking at MLS themselves might have been susceptible to this — but, as seasoned Zillow aficionados even before we got serious about buying, we were more than comfortable looking at listings and creating a gameplan with our agent.


With these new rules only being a few weeks old, it’s hard to say how these updates will truly impact homebuyers and sellers going forward. Instead, we’ll likely need to wait to see what kinds of trends emerge — along with the inevitable loopholes that will be discovered as well. Ultimately, though, what’s most important is that buyers understand what they’re entering into when signing contracts with realtors and are prepared to pay the negotiated commission if need be. Hopefully, however, these adjustments will eventually prove to be a win for all involved.

Author

Kyle Burbank

Head Writer ~ Fioney
Kyle is the head writer for Fioney. He is a personal finance nerd, constantly looking for new apps and services to test and incorporate into his own financial game plan. In addition to his role at Fioney, he's written for other publications including Born2Invest, Lifehack, and Laughing Place, as well as his own site Money@30. He also creates personal finance and travel-related videos for Fioney's YouTube channel, which has garnered more than 2 million views. Currently, Kyle resides in Springfield, Missouri with his wife of 10 years. Together, they enjoy traveling (including visiting Disney Parks around the world), dining, and playing with their dog Rigby.

Other Articles by Kyle Burbank

One Key credit cards and a woman on a boat

Wells Fargo Offering Enhanced Bonuses for One Key Cards

Wells Fargo has unveiled limited-time welcome offers for both of its One Key co-branded credit cards. About the bonuses: Those who have had their eyes on One Key's rewards credit card options may want to take advantage of the increased bonuses that are available now. Currently, new One Key cardholders can earn $400 in OneKeyCash after spending $1,000 in purchases on the card within their first three months. Meanwhile, those...
American Express Member Week March 17-21

American Express Announces March Member Week Celebration

In celebration of its 175th anniversary, American Express has announced that it will be hosting Member Week next month. About Amex Members Week: Amex is bringing back Members Week for 2025 — this time launching the affair in March as opposed to the traditional fall timeframe. This latest event also marks the first time the company has celebrated it since the 2023 edition. 2025's American Express Member Week will be...
Gasbuddy+ Mastercard

GasBuddy Introduces Pay with GasBuddy+ MasterCard Debit Card

The popular app GasBuddy is rolling out a new and improved version of its gas rewards debit card. About Pay with GasBuddy+: GasBuddy has announced the launch of the Pay with GasBuddy+ card. This debit card builds upon the previous Pay with GasBuddy card with some new features. Most notably, in contrast to the original card which could only be used at gas stations, the new product allows for purchases...
The "Email" field is empty, you must enter some text to proceed.The text you entered in the "Email" field appears to be invalid, please edit it and try again
Get the Latest News Delivered to Your Inbox
Travelers with two Best Western Credit Cards

Best Western Debuts Two New Rewards Credit Cards

After pausing applications for their previous rewards card, the hotel chain Best Western has unveiled a new pair of rewards credit cards with a new issuer. About the Best Western cards: Best Western is partnering with First Bank & Trust and Mercury Financial to introduce two new co-branded credit cards. First up is the no-annual-fee Best Western Rewards Visa Signature Card. With this card, customers can 4x points on Best...
Marriott Bonvoy card and a woman on vacation

Marriott Bonvoy Bold Card Launches Travel Contest

Chase and Marriott Bonoy have unveiled a special contest while continuing to offer its best-ever welcome bonus. About the welcome bonus and Bold Chat Court Contest: Marriott Bonvoy and Chase have launched a special opportunity called the Bold Chat Court contest. As part of this contest, 10 lucky travelers will be awarded 500,000 Marriott Bonvoy points (for a total of 5 million) as well as $5,000. For this contest, the...
Bilt and All Reward logos

Bilt Adds 2 New Transfer Partners Including First 3:2 Transfer Rate

Bilt is once again expanding its travel transfer rewards program — and is even breaking the mold with one new partner. About the new additions to Bilt: This week, Bilt launched partnerships with two more travel brands: TAP Air Portugal and Accor. As a result, Bilt members will now be able to transfer their points to Miles&Go and ALL Reward, respectively. In total, Bilt now has 18 transfer partners including 13...
Fioney Top 10 Must-Read Personal Finance Articles Septemeber 2024

Top 10 Personal Finance Articles of the Month — September 2024

Welcome to Fioney's look at the top 10 personal finance articles of the month. On the first Friday of each new month, we look back at some of our favorite posts published in the weeks prior and highlight them right here. This includes a mix of sites that have become staples of our lists as well as many first-timers. To start things off this month, we'll look at some articles...

2024 SoFi Checking and Savings Review

Ever since I started taking an interest in the FinTech sector, one company whose name I’ve seen pop up over and over again is SoFi. Lately it seems as though that theme has been sent into overdrive as the company has not only become a household name thanks to its stadium naming rights deal but also because of the company’s continued product expansions. The most interesting development in my mind...